The Difficulty of Being Good by Gurcharan Das
Gurcharan Das is one of the few multifaceted public personalities that we know of in current day India. He had an extremely successful career in Corporate India and has been an equally well read author, besides being a regular columnist in periodicals. What is interesting is that he is able to relate different worlds together and draw parallels where most people fail to see even a connection. This aspect of him makes it very interesting for me to read him.
I have not read his earlier book, though I have owned it since it was released. This book is based on his study of Mahabharata during his academic holiday after his retirement from the corporate world. He studied various versions of Mahabharata, and as it happens to anyone who reads this text, he identifies with certain characters and with some situations and circumstances. He seems to be most influenced by Yudhistra, and his commitment to dharma. He more or less sees the epic from his point of view.
Das has also picked up some driving emotions that create this oldest story of mankind. He has picked up emotions like Duryodhana’s envy, Draupadi’s courage, Karna’s status anxiety (having read Mrityunjay I do not agree here), Arjuna’s despair (not sure if this is the right word for Vishaad) Bhishma’s selflessness, Krishna’s guile, Ashwathama’s revenge, and his favorite character Yudhistra’s duty and remorse. He has tried to elaborate the role of these emotions in events in these characters’ lives and how it drove them for most of their lives. This makes you stop and think about what is the driving emotion in my life, an important question, if we know the answer we may be able to predict or at least understand our behavior. He also looks at these emotions through the lens of current day understanding of them. He draws parallels from today’s corporate or political world to illustrate the point. He often introspects and looks at how his understanding of dharma at various times in life influenced and defined his choices in life.
Author wrote this book while he was trying to understand Dharma through Mahabharata, and probably that is why he has so much focus on Yudhishtra, who is son of Dharma and is often referred to as Dharamraj. Throughout the book he says through various characters and stories from the epic that Dharma is subtle or Sookshma. This essentially means that in the world of Dharma, there are no blacks and white, everything is in context. He also discusses various forms of Dharma, the sva-sharma and the sadharna dharma. Dharma that is bestowed upon you as part of being a community is called sva-dharma and this can come from being born in a particular family, caste or country or by being a part of any other form of categories in the society. For example the dharma of a magistrate is different from that of a shopkeeper. Then there is dharma that comes to you from within, with no impact from anything external from you, it is also said to be coming from your svabhava or something that comes naturally to you like heat comes naturally to fire. The same things can be dharma for one person at a point in time and not so for someone else or for the same person at a different point in time. Everyone faces times in one’s life when it is very difficult to decide what is the right Dharma? Sometimes your sva-dharma and sadharana dharma end up being in conflict and you may have to choose one over the other.
The books talks of moral dilemmas that have no answers. These dilemmas have always existed and would always continue to exist. He looks at the humanity of the characters and also subtly points out to basic human nature which has not changed over eras. He also relates to these dilemmas to current day heroes and anti-heros, and the possible dilemmas that they would have faced and the character they resemble in Mahabharata, and how they behaved from a primary driving emotion.
Author highlights lots of aspects of Mahabharata, history of how the story and characters may have evolved over a period of time when it was re-written time and again. How it has more questions than answers, how it has no black and white characters and how every characters has faltered somewhere during the story. He also looks at the story post the war, which is where most storytellers stop. I particularly liked the first chapter on Duryodhana and his envy, which can be looked at as both right and wrong depending on who is your protagonist in the story. The analysis of envy as a human driving force is really good, but the analysis of the rest of the emotions and how they drove the characters left me wanting.
Written with a global audience in mind, Indian readers would find a lot of repetition and retelling of well known stories. The central story has been told at the beginning, but a part of it is repeated as such in every chapter. Limitation of writing a book on Mahabharata in English is that it is very difficult to find English equivalents of certain words and the meaning never gets conveyed in totality. However if you understand basic Hindi and Sanskrit, you would enjoy the absolute words and the poetic flow.
While reading this, I found a resonance with Amartya Sen’s ‘Identity and Violence’ which would have looked at the epic from the identity angle and how it drove the events in the story. Das has looked at the driving emotion of the characters while the same can be looked upon as the driving identity that drove the actions and finally lead to the Great War.
There is an amazing reading list at the end of the book, which the author has referred to during his course of study. This is going to be my most important take away from the book as I love to read books written around Mahabharata, which in my belief is the most complete book, which encompasses all possible emotions and dilemmas that a human being or position of a human being can face. I agree with the author that there are more questions in the epic than the answers and the discussions and arguments after each question only give us the various perspectives on the questions and the potential answers but rarely the absolute answer.
An interesting read, if you like Indian history and philosophy, or if you are searching for answers for some of your dilemmas. It’s a simple reading but at the same time makes you stop and think about your understanding of your own dharma.https://www.anureviews.com/the-difficulty-of-being-good-by-gurcharan-das/https://i2.wp.com/www.anureviews.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/book2.jpg?fit=251%2C382&ssl=1https://i2.wp.com/www.anureviews.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/book2.jpg?resize=150%2C150&ssl=1Book ReviewsPhilosophySpiritualityGurcharan Das is one of the few multifaceted public personalities that we know of in current day India. He had an extremely successful career in Corporate India and has been an equally well read author, besides being a regular columnist in periodicals. What is interesting is that he is...Anuradha GoyalAnuradha Goyal[email protected]AdministratorAnuradha Goyal is the author of 'The Mouse Charmers - Digital Pioneers of India' , a travel blogger and an Innovation consultant. AnuReviews - her book reviews blog finds a place in Limca Book of Records for being India's biggest book reviews blog. Know More ...Anu Reviews