The Buddha and Dr Fuhrer by Charles Allen
I have often been intrigued about how the excavations are done, how the records of various finds are reconciled and how the archeologists and historians work out the history especially from the pre-historic times. I picked up this book to understand the dynamics of tracing history through archeological evidences.
The book takes you through the excavations of stupas spread across the terai region on the border of India and Nepal towards the end of late 19th century. A stupa that lies in the estate that belonged to an English family is discovered by accident and then carefully excavated by the owner of the estate. All the finds of the excavation that included stone caskets with bone relics and a whole lot of items in precious metals, stones and gems are recorded and shared with the archeological authorities of that time. One of the caskets has an inscription on it that went around the world for an interpretation and is commonly believed to say that the bone relics belong to the Buddha himself, a part of the relics received by his kinsmen when they were divided into 8 parts.
What is happening parallely is a series of archeologists wanting to find the exact location of Kapilavastu, the city where Buddha grew up based on the accounts of two Chinese travelers who travelled across India some two centuries apart from each other. Both of them recorded a visit to Kapilavastu and described the stupas and the city there but the accounts are a bit different and do not lead to the same place. Since there was a huge time gap between their travels, things could have changed and so could have their writings or there can always be a human error in recording by one of them or some details could have been lost in translation. Nonetheless a few archeologists who wanted to lay claim to the discovery of the city indulged in all kinds of activities like travelling between Nepal and India in Terai region which required a lot of permissions from Nepalese durbar during those days, excavating mounds that were spread across the area, finding Asoka pillars wherever they could, and deciphering inscriptions as and when they found them. Some people even indulged in tempering with the evidences to give strength to their beliefs or to prove their discoveries. There are various claims regarding the actual location of Kapilavastu, and we still cannot say if we know it and this debate will go on till a solid discovery is made that settles it.
Now apart from the learning about the actual account of these discoveries what this book gives you insight into is the working of the British Government at the turn of the 20th century, their holding of the large estates in the countryside, the British families that lived here for generations before they went back after India’s independence and the way archeology evolved in India. Before the British started Archeological survey of India, the wealth of ancient India was lying around everywhere, but no one really looked at it as wealth till the British started excavating and to some extent studying these masterpieces. Flipside is that they also took away a large portion of these with them. It tells you about the systematic way in with William Peppe went about excavating and documenting the finds in his estate, how he involved various authorities in the same, how he parted with his finds for the larger good and how he was hounded by people seeking for a pie out of the treasure he discovered, specially the followers of Buddha. It also gives a view of how the inscriptions were read and how even in those days the scholars around the world communicated and collaborated with each other for their research. It also tells you about the interest the British officers had in excavating ancient sites as a lot of them did it on their own expense and in their leisure time and you would admire their discipline to document everything that they found. Of course there are human elements like rivalry, groupism, favoratism etc, but then they make it more of a real story. You also get insight into the early journals that became placeholders for documenting the recent findings.
As a story, you may not find it complete like the sudden death of a scholar in Switzerland is left unexplained. You may not find it interesting unless you have studies the life of Buddha a bit and unless you have some degree on interest in archeological findings. But if the subjects interest you then there is a lot of knowledge that you would gain from this well researched book.
http://www.anureviews.com/the-buddha-and-dr-fuhrer-by-charles-allen/https://i1.wp.com/www.anureviews.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/BUDDHA-AND-DR-FUHRER.jpg?fit=259%2C400https://i1.wp.com/www.anureviews.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/BUDDHA-AND-DR-FUHRER.jpg?resize=150%2C150ArcheologyBook ReviewsI have often been intrigued about how the excavations are done, how the records of various finds are reconciled and how the archeologists and historians work out the history especially from the pre-historic times. I picked up this book to understand the dynamics of tracing history through archeological evidences. The...Anuradha GoyalAnuradha Goyalanureviews@gmail.comAdministratorAnuradha Goyal is the author of 'The Mouse Charmers - Digital Pioneers of India' , a travel blogger and an Innovation consultant. AnuReviews - her book reviews blog finds a place in Limca Book of Records for being India's biggest book reviews blog. Know More ...Anu Reviews